← Back to all articles

Medicare Myths: 10 Things People Get Wrong, and the Facts

Woman checks Medicare enrollment timing beside her card

Most Medicare mistakes start with a belief that sounds reasonable: Medicare begins when you retire, it is free, or you can sign up whenever you like. Each of those is wrong, and some of them cost people a permanent penalty or a coverage gap. Below are ten common myths, what the official sources say instead, and what to do about each. If you live in Central Oregon, we also cover a myth that costs people money every year: that you are stuck with your Medigap plan.

Mountaintop Insurance
Get Clearer About Medicare
Mountaintop Insurance offers local, personalized Medicare guidance focused on helping Central Oregon residents understand their options and deadlines.

TL;DR

  • Medicare eligibility starts at 65, not at retirement, and you are only enrolled automatically if you already receive Social Security or Railroad Retirement benefits.
  • Medicare is not free for most people. Part B has a monthly premium, a deductible and 20% coinsurance, and there is no yearly out-of-pocket limit in Original Medicare.
  • Missing your enrollment window can mean a lifelong penalty, so the timing matters more than almost any other choice.
  • Medigap and Medicare Advantage cannot be combined, and Medigap needs both Part A and Part B.
  • In Oregon, the Medigap birthday rule lets you compare prices and switch plans without health questions every year.

Table of Contents

Myth 1: Your Medicare card will arrive in the mail

The facts: It arrives automatically only if you are already collecting Social Security or Railroad Retirement Board benefits. Medicare.gov says that if you receive those benefits at least 4 months before turning 65, you are enrolled in Part A and Part B automatically, and your welcome package and card are mailed 3 months before coverage starts.

If you are not yet drawing Social Security, Oregon’s SHIBA program (the state’s free Medicare counseling service) says you usually must contact Social Security yourself, starting 3 months before your birthday month. Nothing will show up in your mailbox to remind you.

What to do: Check your Social Security status at 64. If you are not collecting benefits, put the start of your enrollment window on your calendar. Our Medicare Enrollment Assistance service exists for exactly this moment.

Myth 2: Medicare starts when you retire

The facts: Medicare is tied to age, not retirement. CMS describes the Initial Enrollment Period as a 7-month window: it begins 3 months before the month you turn 65, includes your birthday month, and ends 3 months after. Medicare and Social Security are separate programs, and SHIBA notes that Medicare starts at 65 no matter when you choose to draw Social Security. Waiting until 66 to sign up can bring premium penalties and delayed coverage.

Seven-month Medicare Initial Enrollment Period timeline

There are earlier routes too. Medicare.gov says people with a disability, End-Stage Renal Disease or ALS may qualify before 65.

What to do: Work out your window from your birth month, then decide what to do about any job-based coverage you have (see Myth 5).

Myth 3: Medicare is free

The facts: Part A is premium-free for most people, per SHIBA. Part B is not. New Jersey’s official 2026 premium schedule lists the standard 2026 Part B premium at $202.90 a month, up from $185 in 2025. Higher earners pay more through income-related surcharges (IRMAA): the same document shows $284.10 a month for individuals with 2024 income of $109,001 to $137,000, rising to $689.90 above $500,000.

The premium is only part of it. For 2026 the Part B deductible is $283, and after that you generally pay 20% of the cost of most services. These amounts are reset each year, so look at the current figures on Medicare.gov when you plan.

And there is no cap. Medicare.gov says Original Medicare has no limit on annual out-of-pocket spending unless you add supplemental coverage such as Medigap, Medicaid, or employer, retiree or union coverage.

What to do: Budget for the Part B premium and for the 20% coinsurance, then decide how you want the gap covered. That decision is where a plan review pays for itself.

Myth 3: Medicare is free

Myth 4: You can enroll whenever you want

The facts: Medicare runs on deadlines. Medicare.gov explains that if you do not sign up for Part B when first eligible, you may face a monthly penalty for as long as you have Part B, and it grows the longer you wait. CMS adds that most people who miss Part B when first eligible pay this late-enrollment penalty for life.

Drug coverage works the same way. KFF reports that Part D carries a penalty if you go more than 63 days without creditable drug coverage after your Initial Enrollment Period ends. Creditable means the coverage is expected to pay at least as much as standard Medicare drug coverage.

Timing also sets your start date. Per KFF, if you join in the 3 months before turning 65, coverage begins the first day of your birthday month. If you join in or after your birthday month, it begins the first day of the following month.

CMS’s own guidance says the best option for most people about to become eligible is usually to enroll right away or as soon as the window opens, because waiting risks higher costs, late fees and gaps. Our guide to Medicare enrollment periods walks through each window.

Myth 5: You cannot enroll if you or your spouse still work

The facts: You can, and in some cases you should wait. If you or your spouse stop working, Medicare.gov says you get an 8-month Special Enrollment Period to sign up for Part B. Whether you can safely delay depends on whether your employer coverage is “creditable” and whether the employer is large enough for it to count, which is a question for your benefits office and a Medicare advisor.

Two traps are worth knowing. SHIBA states that COBRA does not count as actively working for the purpose of delaying Part B. And CMS’s job aid says that ending Marketplace coverage does not create a Medicare Special Enrollment Period.

What to do: Before you drop or keep any group plan, get the facts for your specific employer coverage. We offer free consultations where we go through your situation with you.

Myth 6: Medicare covers everything

The facts: Original Medicare leaves real gaps. The government’s Medicare & You 2027 handbook says it does not cover some services, including routine physical exams, eye exams and most dental care. Medigap can help with copayments, coinsurance and deductibles, but the same handbook says it generally does not cover long-term care, vision or dental services, hearing aids, eyeglasses or private-duty nursing.

That means out-of-pocket costs for services Medicare skips depend on how you plan for them. As an example of how widely prices for one common screening can vary with and without coverage, see this breakdown of DEXA scan costs without insurance.

What to do: List what you use most: dental cleanings, glasses, hearing, a possible hospital stay. We help Central Oregon residents with dental and vision coverage and with supplemental plans such as hospital indemnity, cancer and critical illness insurance, so the gaps are planned for rather than discovered at the pharmacy counter or the dentist’s desk.

Myth 7: You can take Part A and a supplement, and skip Part B

The facts: SHIBA explains that Medigap and Medicare Advantage both require you to have Parts A and B. A supplement is built to wrap around Original Medicare, so it cannot stand in for it. If you skip Part B to save the premium, you lose the ability to use either of those options.

Myth 8: Medicare Advantage and Medigap are the same thing, or you can have both

The facts: They are different products, and you pick one path. Medicare.gov says Medicare Advantage (Part C) bundles Parts A and B and usually Part D, requires network providers for non-emergency care, and cannot be combined with Medigap. KFF adds that people in Medicare Advantage cannot buy a Medigap policy.

Original Medicare, by contrast, lets you see any doctor or hospital in the U.S. that takes Medicare.

Advantage plans also change. The Minnesota Department of Aging notes that Medicare Advantage plans can make year-to-year changes that greatly affect benefits, including networks, covered drugs and costs. That is why a yearly look at your plan matters. The Open Enrollment Period runs October 15 to December 7 each year, with changes taking effect January 1, per CMS. Our Annual Medicare Plan Reviews cover that check, and our article on Medicare Advantage open enrollment explains the dates and rules.

Myth 9: Once you pick a Medigap plan, you are stuck with it

The facts: In Oregon you are not. The state has a birthday rule, and it is one of the most useful and least used protections for people on a supplement.

Per Oregon’s Division of Financial Regulation, you can compare Medigap prices and switch companies in a window that runs from 30 days before your birthday to 30 days after. The switch is guaranteed regardless of your health. The catch: you must keep the same plan type or choose one with lesser benefits, following the state’s replacement matrix. For example, someone on a 2010 Plan F can move to any 2010 Plan A through N except an Innovative Plan F.

A few practical rules from the state’s birthday rule fact sheet:

  • New coverage typically starts the first of the month after you apply, which can be before your birthday.
  • Self-funded employer group Medigap plans are not eligible.
  • Switching mid-year between Plan F High Deductible policies restarts the high deductible.
  • Do not cancel your current policy until the new one is issued. Cancelling early can leave you uncovered, while overlapping can mean paying two premiums for one month.

The state’s matrix also notes the rule applies to policies issued after January 1, 1990.

Birthday rule point What it means for you
Window 30 days before to 30 days after your birthday
Health questions None for the switch
Plan choice Same plan type or lesser benefits
Start date Typically the first of the month after you apply
Current policy Keep it until the new one is issued

What to do: If you are paying more than you need to for a supplement, your birthday is the date to act on. Our articles on the Oregon birthday rule and on how to switch Medigap plans lay out the steps, and our Medigap in Oregon guide explains plans and costs.

Myth 10: You can always buy Medigap later without a problem

The facts: Timing again. KFF explains that Medigap insurers must issue policies to people 65 or older regardless of health status when they first enroll in Medicare. In most states, though, people with pre-existing conditions may be denied or charged more if they apply after their first six months of Part B. People who leave Medicare Advantage within 12 months of first enrolling keep the right to buy Medigap without medical underwriting.

Oregon has its own rules, which we explain in our pieces on Medigap and pre-existing conditions and guaranteed issue rights. If you are on Medicare Advantage and want to go back, see Medicare Advantage disenrollment.

Two more worth correcting

“I must spend all my savings before I can get help paying for Medicare.” The Minnesota Department of Aging’s Medicare Myth Busters rebuts this directly. Help programs exist, and your Medicare advisor or SHIBA counselor can point you to them.

“Spouses share one Medicare plan.” Each person enrolls on their own. A spouse can qualify through the other’s work record, but each person has their own coverage, card and premiums.

If you are not a U.S. citizen, note one recent rule. Per CMS’s job aid, beginning July 4, 2025, Medicare eligibility is limited to U.S. citizens, U.S. nationals, lawful permanent residents, Cuban-Haitian entrants and COFA migrants. Anyone who does not qualify is disenrolled 18 months after that date.

Where to start if you are turning 65 in Central Oregon

Here is a simple order of operations:

  1. Find your window. Count 3 months back from your birthday month. That is when you can first sign up.
  2. Check your Social Security status. If you are not drawing benefits, you will need to sign up yourself.
  3. Review any job-based coverage. Find out whether it is creditable before you delay anything.
  4. Choose a path. Original Medicare with a Medigap supplement and a Part D drug plan, or Medicare Advantage. Remember you cannot mix Advantage and Medigap.
  5. Plan for the gaps. Dental, vision and hearing are not part of Original Medicare.
  6. Set a yearly review. Plans, prices and networks change, and in Oregon your birthday opens a window to switch Medigap.

Our step-by-step guide on what to do when turning 65 and our list of common mistakes when enrolling at 65 go deeper on each step.

Talk it through with a local agent

Mountain Top Insurance is a local agency in Bend that helps Central Oregon residents with Medicare Parts A, B, C and D, Medigap including the Oregon birthday rule, and dental and vision coverage. Our approach is education first, and consultations are free, in person or remote. You leave knowing your options and your deadlines. Start with Medicare Eligibility or see our Medicare Supplement plans.

Our perspective

Most of the people who come to us are not confused because they are careless. They are confused because Medicare is built in layers, and each layer has its own deadline. A myth usually starts as a half-truth: Part A is premium-free, so Medicare must be free. Social Security starts when you retire, so Medicare must too.

We think the fix is education before any decision. When you understand the windows, the penalties and the difference between Original Medicare with a supplement and Medicare Advantage, the choice gets much simpler. That is why our consultations are free and why we are local: we would rather you walk in with questions a month before your birthday than call us after a deadline has passed.

For Oregonians already on a Medigap plan, the birthday rule is the part we most want people to hear about. It is a yearly chance to look at your price again without health questions. If you have never checked, your next birthday is the time.

Jesse Zimmerman

FAQ

Am I automatically enrolled in Medicare at 65?

Only if you already receive Social Security or Railroad Retirement Board benefits at least 4 months before your 65th birthday. In that case you are enrolled in Parts A and B and your card is mailed about 3 months before coverage starts. If not, you need to sign up yourself.

What happens if I miss my Medicare enrollment window?

Most people who miss Part B when first eligible pay a late-enrollment penalty for as long as they have Part B, according to CMS. Part D has its own penalty after 63 days without creditable drug coverage. If you or a spouse stop working, an 8-month Special Enrollment Period may apply for Part B.

Can I have Medicare Advantage and a Medigap plan together?

No. Medigap works with Original Medicare, and people enrolled in Medicare Advantage cannot buy one. You choose one path, and you can review that choice during the yearly Open Enrollment Period.

How does the Oregon Medigap birthday rule work?

From 30 days before your birthday to 30 days after, you can switch to a different company’s Medigap policy without health questions. You must keep the same plan type or pick one with lesser benefits. Keep your current policy until the new one is issued.

Does Medicare cover dental, vision and hearing?

Original Medicare generally does not cover most dental care, routine eye exams, eyeglasses or hearing aids, and Medigap generally does not either. Separate dental and vision coverage can fill that gap.

Sources

Disclaimer: This article is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute personalized advice. Medicare rules and plan details change frequently.

Discuss Your Situation With Us